In that sense, Federer was playing the wrong opponent for what ailed him. Millman isn’t flashy, but he is steady, with a forehand and two-handed backhand that are sturdily built. He’s also smart and level-headed and not prone to mental meltdowns. All of those traits, which have traditionally made Australians such strong competitors, served him well last night. As the match went on, Millman barked at his coach more, but his shots stayed calm.
“I’ve never played anyone’s reputation,” Millman said. “That’s been a constant for me, ever since I started the game.”
“It was a slightly intimidating environment. At the start I don’t think I was playing so well. But as the match went on, I felt more comfortable, felt pretty good.”
“I’m just glad, you know, I took the chance today.”
Millman said Federer is a hero of his, and they’ve had their share of conversations and practice sessions together over the years. He acknowledged that Federer “didn’t have a great day in the office,” and that he felt “a little bit guilty” about taking advantage of that. When Federer’s last forehand sailed long, Millman just put his head down and walked to the net.
Millman sounded the way millions of tennis fans felt: Sad to see the 37-year-old legend laid low in a way he’d never been laid low before. Monday’s performance may or may not be a sign of Federer’s ultimate decline, but it is a sign that he’s mortal. That fact might seem obvious, and it would seem obvious with just about anyone else. But it was still a shock to be reminded that it’s true for Federer, too. The quiet that came over Arthur Ashe Stadium, where it is never quiet, was the reaction of an audience watching a great dancer who couldn’t get off the ground. Federer’s body was there, but the liveliness had gone out of it, and the magic had gone out of his racquet. This time it was Federer who lost the big points, who let leads slip and drilled easy volleys into the net. This time it was his unheralded opponent, Millman, who took charge when it mattered.
“Even in some bigger matches that I’ve played,” Millman said, “I’ve always felt as if I’ve done a good job of not letting the moment get the better of me.”
When his moment finally came after 10 years on tour, he was ready. Millmania may not last longer than 15 minutes, but it will have been well-earned.