The ATP’s new year has gotten off to something of a rocky start in Doha. In his first-round match, David Ferrer, after digging a hole for himself in the first set against 167th-ranked Dustin Brown, dug a literal hole in the court with his right foot during a point. Fortunately for Ferru, if not the few fans in the seats, it took 55 minutes to fix. By then Brown’s momentum was a distant memory.
To the close-listening fan, though, what was more interesting about the Ferrer-Brown match was what happened before it began. As the two players waited for the coin toss, chair umpire Cedric Mourier informed them that he would be enforcing the 25-second-between-point time rule more strictly than in the past, and that if they had any questions about how long they were taking, they should ask him. Mourier’s warning may have sounded innocuous—if there's a rule, why shouldn’t an umpire enforce it?—but the speed-it-up effort behind it was destined to cause trouble this week.
It didn’t take long. First Feliciano Lopez and then Gael Monfils were hit with time-violation penalties, and each suffered a mini-meltdown in response. Lopez, who had a first serve taken away from him when he was down triple set point (it was his second violation of the match), never recovered and lost in straight sets to Lukas Kubot. Monfils, who was warned for taking too much time to towel off, gave away the second set to Philip Kohlschreiber in protest before gathering himself to win the third. (See the clip at the bottom of this post for Monfils' interesting explanation of why he needed to spend so much time with the towel. I think we have an early contestant for Quote of the Year.)
This, obviously, isn’t the last we’re going to hear on the subject. The men aren’t used to staying strictly within the time limits between points; but the tour, after years of plodding play, finally seems determined to make them. Starting this year, after giving one warning, chair umpires can take away a player’s first serve if there’s a second violation. In the past, the umpire had to dock the player a point, something very few were willing to do. The hope is that the lesser penalty will encourage the umpires to be bolder in issuing them.
Now we’re getting a look at the new system in action. It will likely be ugly for a little while, and there will be more meltdowns to come. But the ATP is making the right move. With common sense and flexibility in mind, the tour should stick to its guns. This may seem like a no-brainer; as I said, why have a rule if you’re not going to enforce it? But it’s not quite as simple as that. Here’s a look at a few of the questions and issues surrounding how much time is too much on a tennis court.