Question: To Challenge or Not to Challenge Line Calls?

by: Jonathan Scott September 27, 2013

AP Photo

Facebook's chief operating officer, Sheryl Sandberg, famously called on women to "lean in" in the workplace and in their personal lives. The business leader, reportedly worth somewhere between $400 million and $1 billion depending on who you read, probably didn't know how this would be parlayed into a study about WTA and ATP pros and how they challenge line calls in matches. But that's just what Jon Wertheim at Sports Illustrated set out to show, noting that male pros object officially to calls more than their female peers, among other statistics compiled by the Scorecasting scribe. And Slate.com has some statements about the findings, as does discriminating SI reader and letter writer "Dane."

What's interesting is how male and female tennis players are correct in their challenges basically the same percentage of the time, even if the WTA's pros don't challenge as often. So are the women better at it? Are they more easily swayed away from challenging by chair umpires with whom they often inquire first? What do you make of all these numbers?

 

Got a thought, a tip, or a point to make? Hit me on Twitter @jonscott9.

More Stories

Rafael Nadal admits he's not in top form heading into U.S. Open

"The intensity and desire are there," Nadal said. "I hope the wrist starts to feel more comfortable." 

Chile Tennis Federation fined $55,000 for unsuitable court conditions in Davis Cup tie

The Colombian team had complained that the clay court installed by Chile was unfit for play. 

U.S. Open Pressure Points: No. 1 seed Serena Williams and her race against time

Approaching 35 and with a new challenger to her throne, can the all-time great do it again?