INDIAN WELLS, CALIF.—The setting was pristine, as always, but the tennis on Monday was messy, sometimes ugly, and often surprising. How many times have two defending champions gone out in back-to-back matches this early? I’ll get to the biggest upset of the afternoon, Rafael Nadal’s loss to Alexandr Dogolpolov, tomorrow; for now, here’s a look at some of the day’s other notable results, including its other stunner, Maria Sharapova’s loss to Camila Giorgi.
*
Attack of the Clone
One thing we know about Sharapova: She doesn’t like playing a Mini-Me. As the Portuguese tennis journalist Miguel Seabra pointed out, last year at Wimbledon she lost to Michelle Larcher de Brito, this year at the Australian Open she lost to Dominika Cibulkova, and today she lost to Camila Giorgi.
What do these three women have in common, aside from the fact that they’re all ranked well below Sharapova and have never approached what she’s done in her career? Two things: They’re all significantly shorter than the 6’2” Sharapova—most people are—and they all play something like her. They swing hard and flat, for the fences, and they do it from a lower trajectory than she does.
Sharapova’s coach, Sven Groeneveld, seemed to understand the issue when he came out to talk to her on a couple of changeovers. “Lower your center of gravity,” he told her over and over. It worked for a while in the second set, but there was no advice anyone could give that would have helped Maria today. She finished with 16 winners and 58 unforced errors, a stat-line that normally wouldn't get you anywhere close to a victory.