“I don’t know how the week was,” said world No. 2 Angelique Kerber on Sunday, "because I’m really tired.”

It’s an assessment that casual and hardcore tennis fans might want to consider echoing. The knee-jerk reaction to Kerber’s 6-3, 6-1 loss to Karolina Pliskova in Cincinnati was that the German folded with the No. 1 ranking for the taking. Serena Williams’ relative struggles in 2016 combined with Kerber’s all-surface consistency meant that the American was in danger of surrendering the top spot on tour for the first time in 184 weeks. Fresh off a straight-sets victory over Simona Halep in the semis, Kerber’s coronation appeared to be at hand.

But the Australian Open champion wasn’t able to make the necessary final push, just as she wasn’t at Wimbledon and the Olympic Games, where she also finished second. (Could there be a more fitting world No. 2?) This is not a slight considering the compressed summer schedule. Kerber has posted all of these impressive results, including a trip to the semifinals of the Rogers Cup, in a roughly month-and-a-half span across three continents. With the spotlight intensifying following her maiden major title, and after having dealt with illness during the clay-court season, Kerber has demonstrated what so many Top 10 players in the WTA have lacked: deep runs in big tournaments, week after week.

Advertising

And yet, can we consider her loss to Pliskova anything but a disappointment? She “repeatedly missed routine shots,” according to the Associated Press, and was the clear favorite to Pliskova, who won her first WTA Premier-level trophy. "I was expecting I'm going to play good, but I wasn't expecting it that easy,” said Pliskova. "I think [Kerber] might be a little bit tired, or she felt a little bit of pressure on herself."

We know what Kerber is capable of, and it’s been a pleasure to watch her harness the most from of her obvious talents this season. Her game mixes all elements of the modern baseline game—speed, spin, opportunism, defense, stamina—to create havoc for any opponent. But not on Sunday, short of one notable highlight.

Advertising

It all leads to the U.S. Open, where we will have to see if Kerber can put together yet another prolonged run. The No. 1 ranking has never seemed to be Kerber’s main motivation, but the significance of it surely isn’t lost on her.

It all may depend on the health of Williams, who was a late withdrawal from Cincinnati. Assuming she’s in proper form at Flushing Meadows, the third installment of Kerber vs. Williams in this year’s major finals would be a fitting way to conclude the Grand Slam season. The rubber match would also likely be for the No. 1 ranking.

At that point, no matter how tired they or we are after a relentless tennis summer, all questions will be answered.